Opinion

A Close Call with Knockoffs Illustrates Problems in Jewelry

A ring by jewelry designer Polly Wales was a subject of interest in a jewelers' group on Saturday morning.

New York City. Dec. 3, 2018. On Saturday morning as I sat sipping my coffee and scrolling through Facebook, I came across a request on a closed trade-only jewelry forum called Jewelers Helping Jewelers (JHJ). Would the group of more than 14,000 individuals please weigh in to help the poster, a jeweler, learn how to copy the handiwork of an established jewelry designer with a recognizable aesthetic since one of his good customers liked it? The designer was Polly Wales, a pioneer in the cast-not-set technique of wax-cast jewelry with gemstones.

Advertise

Jennifer Heebner Connecting Jewelers and Collectors

To advertise, contact Nicole@thejewelrybook.com.

I nearly spit out my coffee—not because somebody else was yet again trying to copy the hard work of another individual but because that person had taken the request to a huge public forum to expedite the offense. By the time I saw the post, it had been online for about 16 hours, allowing ample time for others to weigh in. But instead of posts of protest à la, “That’s not ethical behavior,” they responded with ugly comments about the designer’s signature aesthetic, an organic-looking method of casting specific gemstones securely into precious metal.

A short-lived online discussion ensued before the poster, I imagine, deleted the entire thread. Perhaps he realized that time stamps and motive were present, which could provide evidence that he intended to take money out of the established designer’s pocket and put it into his own. I’m not a lawyer or a policewoman, but as a journalist with 22 years of experience writing about serious industry issues like this, it’s appropriate to point out questionable behavior for the benefit of many. Over the summer, I even helped to organize a conference for the New York Metro chapter of the Women’s Jewelry Association where intellectual property (IP) lawyers offered insight into alleged claims of knockoffs—which is where I learned about time stamping and willful efforts to deceive. If the now-deleted JHJ thread became public knowledge, it could be a black eye to many in jewelry. I’m thrilled the jeweler took it down, because its presence lent a measure of authoritativeness to a request that could lead many down a dark path.

Advertise

Jennifer Heebner Connecting Jewelers and Collectors

To advertise, contact Nicole@thejewelrybook.com.

This certainly isn’t the first time IP issues have come under scrutiny, nor will it be the last. But learning from them—quickly—and turning the situation around is always the best course of action for all parties involved.

Jennifer Heebner LLC

This content is copyright protected and may not be reproduced.

Share this Story
Load More Related Articles
Load More By Jennifer Heebner
Load More In Opinion

Leave a Reply

Check Also

Live from SIHH: Richard Mille’s Bonbon Watch Collection is the Sweet Fix You Need Today

Geneva, Jan. 22, 2019. Get your sugar buzz ...

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Instagram

  • Happy spring from the Heebners! These are our tulip beds.
.
.
.
#journalist #Influencer #JeweleryAddict #journolife #JeweleryLover #stories #JewelryOfTheDay #springflowers #jewelry #lovegold #jewelrylover #jewelrypeople #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #jewelrygoals #gorgeousjewels #editor #reporter #tellmeyourstory #writersofinstagram #gardener #tuliplover #journalist #journalism #jewelry #flowergirl #reporterlife #flourtownpa #tulips #flowers
  • Another highlight from the Tucson shows? Holding these juicy jewels from @kmitadesign. Wonder if they will still be around by Vegas?
.
.
.
#journalist #Influencer #JeweleryAddict #journolife #JeweleryLover #stories #JewelryOfTheDay #jewellery #jewelry #lovegold #jewelrylover #jewelrypeople #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #jewelrygoals #gorgeousjewels #editor #reporter #tellmeyourstory #writersofinstagram #jewelryshow #jewelryporn #journalist #journalism #jewelry #jewelrycollector #reporterlife #gems #tucson #gemstones
  • It’s almost time for... @jewelry_independent!
.
.
.
We have reached the end of May Summit Registration. Today and Tomorrow you can use code LASTCALL to receive 25% off of your streaming tickets. •
•
•
Streaming tickets can be used to watch the Summit live on May 4th. This ticket option also provides access to the complete summit from May 6th-June 6th where you can watch as many times as you like.
•
•
We are welcoming @thirdcoastgems @tanyadukes @plandeville @catherinepdv @laurenpainter @bergdorfs @francescasconsulting @jewelsbygrace @engagement101 @alainsimic @arielleratner @arianaboussardreifel @wwake @for_future_reference @danabronfman @jenniferheebner and moderator @milestones_by_ab. You won’t want to miss this one! Visit jewelryindepdent.com and buy your tickets now!
  • Adorable silver, vermeil, and enamel jewels from @giulianadifranco_jewels. This was a highlight from the Tucson shows this year!
.
This Sicilian maker tells stories of Italy in wearable form.
.
Pieces from the Amori Siciliani collection, some shown here, tell the tale of the Myth of the Moor love affair with a girl from Palermo. (It didn’t end well for him.)
.
The couple embracing (my fave!) are in traditional Sicilian clothes and are part of the Novella Rusticana collection.
.
The final piece, an oval-shape pendant, is from the Gondi d’Autore collection, and features imagery unique to the landscape of Sicily.
.
More of her collections tell other somewhat literal tales—think citrus fruits, divine!—but all capture the spirit of the artist’s countryside in painstaking miniature with masterful enamel work by a Sicilian painter.
.
.
.
#journalist #Influencer #JeweleryAddict #journolife #JeweleryLover #stories #JewelryOfTheDay #jewellery #jewelry #lovegold #jewelrylover #jewelrypeople #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #jewelrygoals #gorgeousjewels #editor #reporter #tellmeyourstory #writersofinstagram #jewelryshow #jewelryporn #journalist #journalism #jewelry #jewelrycollector #reporterlife #italy #sicily #italiandesign
  • That time in @baselworldofficial when @roberto_coin unveiled craft big gold bracelets in his Rock and Diamonds collection. Even without diamonds, these are next-level cool.
.
.
.
#journalist #Influencer #JeweleryAddict #journolife #JeweleryLover #gemstory #JewelryOfTheDay #jewellery #jewelry #lovegold #jewelrylover #jewelrypeople #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #jewelrygoals #gorgeousjewels #editor #tellmeyourstory #writersofinstagram #robertocoin #jewelryporn #journalist #journalism #jewelry #jewelrycollector #reporterlife #goldbracelet #gold #lovegold
  • Nothing like some bold gold to set the mood for spring!! @mattiolijewelry at @baselworldofficial.
.
.
.
#journalist #Influencer #JeweleryAddict #journolife #JeweleryLover #gemstory #JewelryOfTheDay #jewellery #jewelry #lovegold #jewelrylover #jewelrypeople #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #jewelrygoals #gorgeousjewels #editor #tellmeyourstory #writersofinstagram #sapphires #jewelryporn #journalist #journalism #jewelry #jewelrycollector #reporterlife #goldnecklace #gold #lovegold
  • These pretty, happy pearl creations from @utopiajewelsmilano are like soap bubbles in the sun, glistening in clusters of pure polychromatic joy. There’s never been a better time to fall in love with pearls. As seen at the recent @baselworldofficial fair.
.
.
.
#THISispearl #pearlicious #FarmedNotMined #PearlsJam #LiveLoveLuster #journalist #tahitianpearls #Pearls #JeweleryAddict #JeweleryLover #pearllover #Pearl #green #jewelry #journalist #JeweleryAddict #journolife #jewelrylover #jewelrypeople #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #jewelrygoals #gorgeousjewels #editor #writersofinstagram #journalist #journalism #jewelry #jewelrycollector #reporterlife
  • Hello more unheated rubies and big honking diamonds from @picchiotti_fine_jewellery! As seen in @baselworldofficial.
.
.
.
#jewelrylover #jewelrylife #jewelrygram #editor #gorgeousjewels #raregems #tellmeyourstory #jewelrystories #writersofinstagram #gemstones #jewelryporn #journalist #journalism #journolife #jewelry #jewelryaddict #gemcollector #gemsofinstagram #collectors #reporterlife

Follow Me!